Maintenance should be based on evidence
Thorough inquiry should be made to ascertain the actual needs of the Children
Actual Custody can be shared
Actual custody just like legal custody can be shared between parents.
Parental Responsibility Agreement
Parental responsibility Agreement can be vitiated just like any other contract
Step-mother Vs. mother
There should be evidence that a child will get along with a step-parent
Tender years exception
A mother must reside with child of tender years and if not the tender years rule will not apply
Tender years exception
Behavior of the mother after separation is paramount
Minimal disruption in children lives
The court favors the least inconvenience to a child when making an order
Parents are the most ideal
Parents to a child are the most ideal to provide the rights over their children
Granting of stay in children matters
Granting of stay orders should consider the best interest of the Minor.
Opinion of a child should be objective
The best interests of a child must not be dictated by the opinion of a child
Kadhis Court jurisdiction
Kadhis court do not have jurisdiction over children matters
Interim orders
Interim orders in a trial court should not be interfered with without appeal full hearing
Jurisdiction DNA test
The Children's court has jurisdiction to order for DNA test
Res Judicata in Children matters
Res Judicata cannot stop a court from revisiting a children's matter
status quo during suit
During pendency of the suit status quo should be maintained to avoid disruption of Minor
Best Interests of Child
A child's best interests overrides the interests of the parents.
Advisory opinion of the Supreme Court
Should be treated as authoritative statement of the law.
Access on alternate weekdays unsuitable
To grant access (custody) on alternate weekdays is unsuitable for children
Access orders should be clear
Orders on access of the child must be clear
Separation of siblings
Making custody orders that separate siblings is not in their best interests
Abrupt changing of school hazardous
Removing a child from one school to another as a result of custody orders is detrimental
Article 50(2) of the Constitution
Article 50(2) of the Constitution applies to the Accused person only.
chargee's power of sale
An error in computing interest cannot fetter chargee's power of sale
Test for Constitutionality of statute
The test of constitutional is stated to be nothing but a formal test of rationality.
Interpretation of the constitution
It should be given a holistic interpretation and read as an entity.
Interpretation of a statute
Both purpose and effect should be looked at to ascertain the constitutional validity.
Provisions on fundamental human rights
Should be given a dynamic, progressive, liberal and flexible interpretation.
substantial question of law
Public importance should be considered in establishing any question of law.
Best interests of the child
The best interests of any child are paramount as compared to any rights of a parent
Literal rule of interpretation
when the language is clear, it should be taken expressly as conclusive
Public participation
It ought to be real and not illusory and should not be treated as mere formality.
Gender rule in political parties
Political parties should decide on how to incorporate the gender principles
Two third gender rule
it's an important element of human rights protected under the Constitution.
Nature of a superior court's obiter
Obiter of superior court is persuasive in the lower courts.
Article 27 of the Constitution
Applies irrespective of the context in which discrimination occurs.
Equality of the law
It's philosophical foundation of human rights and basic tenet of justice
Right to vote
it's a basic structure in a democratic society and should only be limited within the law
Bail and Bond
Right to bail/bond is not absolute and when it could be restricted.
Bail and Bond
Balancing State interest vs Individual rights in bail/bond application.
Bail and Bond
Application of Strict scrutiny rule.
Bail and Bond
Criteria for granting or denying bail/bond.
Bail and Bond
Right to bail/bond is not absolute and when it could be restricted.
Bail and Bond
Guidelines to determine whether bail/bond is excessive.
Bail and Bond
Bail pending appeal.
Interpretation of the law
courts have power to make law when necessary to meet the end of justice.
Interpretation of the constitution
It should be given purposive approach.
Determination of constitutional queries
Must be determined in conformity with the constitutional principles.
Best interests of the child
Complete welfare of a child is to be given priority as compared to monetary needs.
Interpretation of the constitution
It should not be interpreted necessarily according to the general rules of statutory interpretation.
Judicial function in matters Law
Espouse the value system in the Constitution and to avoid structural minimalistic approach.
Article 20(3) of the constitution
Holistic approach to the Article imports a limited legislative role to the High court
Article 10 of the constitution
national values and principles under the article are not exclusive but inclusive.
Limitation of CAP 2 Laws of Kenya
Cannot be invoked in the construction and interpretation of the Constitution.
validity of an executive action
validity depends on the legal principles surrounding the action and laws appurtenant to the action.
Jurisdiction of the High Court
It's obliged to intervene in actions by arms of the government in cases of constitutional violations
Doctrine of separation of powers
High court has power to inquire into the constitutionality of actions irrespective of the doctrine.
Doctrine of separation of powers
Must be read in the context of the constitutional framework.
Doctrine of separation of powers
In cases of a conflict, the doctrine must bow to the spirit and the letter of the Constitution.
Nature of the constitution
It's not a structurally based document but value oriented.
Nature of the constitution
Interpretation and application must be ingrained in the spirit of the Constitution and values.
Decisions emanating from the government
must be taken to ensure that such decision conform to the trans formative constitutional framework.
The Citizenship (Amendment) Act 2019
Declares groups of persons from Afghanistan, Bangladesh or Pakistan as not illegal persons.
Custody of a female child
Custody of a female child should be granted to the mother owing to the fact that she is vulnerable
Parental responsibility
The needs of a child should be guided by the income earned by each parent
Parental responsibility
Both parents have the responsibility to maintain the children despite their earning capacity
Actual custody
A mother can be granted actual custody despite not being able to maintain the child
Actual custody to third parties
It deprives a child of the parental care necessary for growth if he or she has both parents alive
Custody of children of tender years
The custody of children of tender years should not be based solely on material provisions
Access to children by parents
Courts have the discretion to determine the access terms for children putting their interests first
Custody of a child
Views of children with regard to determining custody orders should also be put into consideration
Custody and access to a child
Both parents have to be involved in a child's life despite one parent having solely access orders
Custody of a tender child to the father
A father has to prove for special circumstances in which he should be granted custody of a child
Standing orders of the parliament
Reflects parliamentary policy of undertaking the Assembly's constitutional and legislative mandate.
Standing orders of the parliament
Constitute legislation that must be obeyed and respected.
Standing orders of the parliament
they are within the purview of Article 10 of the Constitution
Jurisdiction matters
After the matter has been dispensed off, no party will be allowed to raise it in later stages.
Jurisdiction matters
The court should decide the matter depending on the material before it.
Jurisdiction matters
Without jurisdiction, the court downs its tools and has no power to make one more step.
Standing orders of the parliament
Courts have the competence to pronounce on the compliance by the legislative body in matters law.
Nature of the Kenyan constitution
Constitution 2010 is a trans-formative charter.
Appeal against a conviction
One cannot appeal against a conviction on one's own guilty plea except to the legality of the plea.
Test for a defective charge sheet
The test is a substantive one and not a formalistic one
Overloading of Charge Sheet.
Preferably, no more than 12 counts should be laid in one charge sheet.
when can a retrial be ordered
A retrial can only be ordered where the court is convinced that conviction can be achieved
when can a charge be duplex
If they are two independent charges, one cannot be subsumed in the other
When can a retrial be ordered
Circumstances in which a retrial can be ordered.
The conduct of public participation
dissemination, invitation and consultation must be incorporated to warrant public participation
Circumstancial evidence &inferring guilt
One should be sure that no other coexisting circumstance would weaken the evidence.
Test for Article 24
Must conform with what has been accepted universally as democratic society.
Test for Article 24
the test must be subjective
Limitations of human rights
There must be pressing social need for restriction on a right.
Limitations of human rights
Direct connection between the expression and the protected interest must be shown.
Proof beyond reasonable doubt
Prosecution must prove its case beyond reasonable doubt.
Dying declaration as evidence
No corroboration is needed for a dying declaration to support conviction.
Use of circumstantial evidence
Justification on use of circumstantial evidence.
Applying circumstantial evidence
Principles to determine whether circumstantial evidence is sufficient to sustain a conviction.
Best interest of a child
Other factors to be considered in the determination of the best interest of a child
Conduct of parent in child's custody
The conduct of a parent during a trial informs the court on the determination of custody
Parental responsibility
A mother can apply for the extension of parental responsibility
Maintenance
Special circumstances ought to be proved for maintenance of an individual of above 18 years
Parental responsibility
DNA is to be submitted for a father to take parental responsibility if the parties are not married
Parental responsibility
Court cannot compel a man to take up parental responsibility of a child if not married to the mother
Relying on Circumstantial evidence
In cases of circumstantial evidence, there is always a danger that suspicion may replace legal proof
Relying on Circumstantial evidence
Total cumulative effect of all the proved circumstances must be conclusive in establishing guilt.
Doctrine of Last Seen
This doctrine must be corroborated so as to establish connectivity between accused and crime.
Relying only on Circumstantial evidence
Prosecution must prove motive on the accused to commit the offence.
Relying only on Circumstantial evidence
Suspicion, however strong cannot form a basis for inferring guilt, but purely based on evidence.
Conviction on Circumstantial evidence
Cumulatively should be so complete, in all human probability, accused committed the crime.
Ingredients of murder
malice aforethought causing death of another person by an unlawful act .
Circumstantial evidence
Circumstantial evidence is best evidence.
Accused burden of innocence
Law places no burden on him to prove his innocence.
Defense of Alibi.
By setting up alibi as defense accused does not assume burden of proving alibi.
Defense of Alibi.
It ought to be raised at the earliest opportunity.
Parental responsibility
Parental responsibility ceases upon completion of undergraduate studies
Presumption of innocence
It is in favor of accused unless state proves otherwise beyond reasonable doubt.
Conduct of parent to be granted custody
A parent can be denied custody if his/her conduct causes harm to the weelbeing of the child
Parental responsibility
Parents to a child share equal parental responsibility regardless of their marital status
Custody to a remarried mother
Remarriage is not reason to disqualify granting custody unless detrimental to the child's welfare
Best interest and relocation
Custodial parent has the right to relocate with child so long as it is in the child's best interest
Custody of a male child
Custody of a male child is granted to the father upon proof of special circumstances
Public Participation
A body that alleges public participation was conducted must prove with sufficient evidence.
Removal of a governor
Any procedure for the removal of a governor from the office must incorporate public participation.
Removal of a governor
The procedure should not be solely vested on the Members of the County Assembly.
Removal of a governor
Any process that involves the removal of a governor must reflect the will of the people.
Threshold of nullifying an Act
It must be proved to the court that the process was fundamentally flawed in enacting the Act
Limits to the Separation of powers
The High Court has constitutional limits in exercising judicial powers in matters legislations.
Jurisdiction of the High Court
invalidation of laws that are unconstitutional is in tandem which the court's duty under Article 163
Article 1 of the Constitution
All state organs must bow to the will of the people as expressed in the Constitution.
Separation of powers
It should not be applied in theoretical purity but the main focus should be towards good governance
Separation of powers
The principle is there to ensure that no single person or organ has the monopoly of power
Jurisdiction of Industrial Courts
Has the same status as the High Court thus vested with jurisdiction similar to those of High Court.
Limitations of Parliament
Cannot plead any internal rule or any statutory scheme as a reprieve from Constitutional obligation
Limitations of Parliament
Must function within the purview of the Constitution.
Limitations of Courts
The court cannot supervise the workings of the Parliament
Application of Law
Must be applied equally to all.
Powers of the Courts
Must be viewed from the supremacy clause under Article 2(1) of the Constitution.
Contempt of the court
Any legislation should not be enacted with the aim of limiting this power of the court.
Contempt of the court
Any legislation on contempt should be in addition to but not in derogation of the Constitution.
Contempt of the court
The power to punish for contempt is inherent thus not vested by the Constitution or Acts.
Contempt of the court
Any statute around contempt of court should only provide on how the power is to be applied.
Contempt of the court
Any statute on contempt of court should make the courts more effective but not limit their powers.
Purpose of the Courts
To ensure that public benefits from its judgments.
Contempt of court as a punishment
The purpose is to insulate courts processes for purposes of compliance
Contempt of court as a punishment
The purpose is to maintain the dignity of the court and make it effective in the justice arena.
disobedience of court orders
Violates the national values and the principles under the Constitution.
Interpretation of the Constitution
Courts should look at the purpose and effect of the legislations.
Burden of proof
It behoves the party alleging the unconstitutionality of an Act to prove to the courts.
Interpretation of the Constitution
Must be construed purposively and in a contextual manner.
Interpretation of the Constitution
Should not be unduly strained and should avoid excessive peering at the language to be interpretated
Interpretation of the Constitution
Generous construction should be adopted over a merely textual or legalistic approach.
Interpretation of the Constitution
A construction that advances the rule of law and promotes the spirit of the Constitution is needed.
Two conflicting interpretations
The court should adopt an interpretation that best advances the principles of the Constitution.
Interpretation of the Constitution
Interpretation should not subvert the societal goals and endanger public good.
Best interests of a child
Parent's new relationship after separation should not interfere with the best interests of a child
Interests of a child
Parents should be involved in the upbringing of a child despite access orders granted to one parent
Bias
Upon trial on a child's matter,judges should be impartial by putting interests of child at priority
Mother's care to female children
The attention of a mother is quite important for girls almost at puberty and adolescent stages
Care for female children
Female children need the care of their mother when they are growing up since they are vulnerable
Extension of parental responsibility
Child above eight years, his or her parent or anyone with parental responsibility may apply
Parents' responsibility in Children Act
Children are to be cared for by parents whether they are born in or out of wedlock
Paramountcy principle
Provides that a child's interest(s) should be a priority over any interests of the parents
Parental care
Mental illness doesn't make a parent unfit for custody unless it negatively impacts on child's care
Custody
Definition of actual custody and legal custody
Relationship between a child and parent
Despite the custody orders, it is important children maintain a relationship with the parents
Sharing of custody
Both actual and legal custody can be joint and shared
Parental responsibility
Parental responsibility is limited to the child's parents unless under special circumstances
Taking and recording of plea of guilt.
The procedure to be undertaken by the trial court when taking and recording an accused plea of guilt
Is a guilty plea unequivocal?
whether a guilty plea is unequivocal or not depends on the circumstances of the case.
Vitiating a guilty plea
Failure to warn accused on minimum sentence of a crime does not vitiate well recorded guilty plea.
Duplex Charge sheet.
Prosecution should not allege commission of more than one offence in a single charge sheet.
Fatally Defective Charge Sheet.
Test for a fatally defective charge sheet.
Test of a defective Charge Sheet.
Test for a defective charge sheet is a substantive one and not a formalistic one.
Preferring charges.
Prosecution has the powers and discretion when preparing the charge sheet and prosecuting.
Preferring charges.
Prosecution has the powers and discretion when preparing the charge sheet and prosecuting.
Objections to a charge sheet
Lawyers should raise objections to a charge sheet if they see likely prejudice.
Rejection of charges
Rejection of charges amounts to a discharge under Criminal Procedure Code.
Right to fair trial.
A charge sheet should give necessary information to accused to fulfill this right.
Pleading when a case starts denovo
Accused does not need to plead afresh when a case starts denovo.
Defective charge sheet
Amendment can be done by court at any stage of a trial before the close of the prosecution case.
Identification of documents.
Documents to be used during trial should be properly marked and listed to enhance convenience
Circumstantial evidence
Admissibility of circumstantial evidence
Circumstantial evidence
Conviction should be justified by total cumulative effect of all the proved circumstances.
Circumstantial evidence
Prosecution to establish motive as one of the chains linking the accused to the crime
Defence of alibi
Prosecution ought to dislodge the accused alibi defence as required in law.
Burden of proof
The law places no burden on a defendant to prove his innocence.
Defence of alibi
Defence of alibi should be raised at the earliest opportunity.
STATUS OF UBER DRIVERS
Uber drivers are employees
Restriction of Minor from jurisdiction
Removing a child from the jurisdiction of court pending a suit can render the case nurgatory.
CONSERVATORY ORDERS IN CRIMINAL MATTERS
ELC has jurisdiction to issue preservatory orders in criminal matters
LETTER OF ALLOTMENT
A letter of allotment is not title to land.
ADVERSE POSSESSION
Gazzetted Magistrates have jurisdiction over adverse possession cases.
PURPOSE OF INTERLOCUTORY ORDERS
Interlocutory orders are meant to preserve the suit property pending the determination of the suit.
LAND DISPUTES TRIBUNALS
Jurisdiction of land dispute tribunals does not include claims of title to land.
SECTION 26 OF THE LAND REGISTRATION ACT
Conditions for impeachment of a title under Section 26 of the Land Registration Act.
CONSTITUTIONAL PETITION UNDER ELC
Conditions for a party to satisfy for constitutional reliefs in ELC matters.
RES JUDICATA CONDITIONS
A party must satisfy certain conditions in order to succeed in a claim for Res Judicata.
NO JURISDICTION OVER SUCCESSION DISPUTES
Environment and land court lacks jurisdiction over succession disputes.
IRREPARABLE DAMAGE
Loosing prime property is irreparable damage.
INTERNAL DISPUTE RESOLUTION MECHANISMS
Statutory dispute mechanisms must be exhausted before approaching the Court for reliefs.
CONSENT REQUIRED BEFORE FILING A SUIT
Under s. 30 (1)Land Adjudication Act, adjudication officer to consent in writing before filing suit
LIMITATION OF ACTIONS
Constitutional Petitions cannot be defeated by doctrine of laches.
CONDITIONS FOR MANDATORY INJUNCTION
Interim Mandatory injunctions have finality to them. They must meet this criteria.
CONSTITUTIONAL PETITION UNDER ELC
Only ELC can hear violation of environmental and land rights.
PUBLIC PARTICIPATION
Lack of public participation may indicate violation of environmental rights.
ADMISSIBILITY OF DOCUMENTS
Mere production of a document as an exhibit does not constitute it's proof.
ADVERSE POSSESSION
A party must prove that the owner of the land lost possession.
JURISDICTION IN SUCCESSION MATTERS
The ELC does not have jurisdiction over succession disputes over a deceased person Estate.
PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS MUST BE CANVASSED
Once pleaded, a Preliminary Objection must be canvassed.
PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS MUST BE CANVASSED
Once pleaded, a Preliminary Objection must be canvassed.
PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS MUST BE CANVASSED
Once pleaded, a Preliminary Objection must be canvassed.
PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS MUST BE CANVASSED
Once pleaded, a Preliminary Objection must be canvassed.
JURISDICTION OVER MULTIPLE CLAIMS
The ELC is the best forum to adjudicate multiple claims over several adjudicating jurisdictions.
JURISDICTION OVER MULTIPLE CLAIMS
The ELC is the best forum to adjudicate multiple claims over several adjudicating jurisdictions.
A child's opinion should be heard
A child's opinion should be heard where possible before making substantive orders.
VEXATIOUS SUIT
Meaning of a suit that is vexatious, frivolous with no cause of action
DEFENCE MUST RAISE TRIABLE ISSUES
A Defence must raise triable issues otherwise it should be struck out.
PRINCIPLES IN STRIKING OUT DEFENCE
A Defence can be struck out upon satisfying certain conditions.
PROCESS OF EXECUTION
A Registrar must make a formal order for execution under O. 43 R3 of the Civil Procedure Rules.
Exception to Tender years rule
A mother who is not staying with the children is an exception to the tender years principle.
Parental Responsibility
A parent who insist on taking a child to private school should bear the fees.
Parental Responsibility
A parent who insist on taking a child to private school should bear the fees.
Actual custody meaning
Actual custody of a child is not equal to ownership of the child
Parents preferred custodians
A child must benefit from parental care and not from third parties
Stay of execution
The tender years principle is not a sufficient ground to stay execution of orders pending appeal.
Tender years exception
Clear evidence must be produced to proof exception to tender years principle.
Stay of execution
Stay of execution of custody in favor of resident parent is not available for absent parent.
Custody of female adolescents
if no execpetions, custody of female adolescent children should be with mother naturally.
Custody to biological parents preferred
Keeping a child away from their biological parents is cruel and against best interests.
Exceptions to the Tender Years Rule
Exceptions to the tender year rule must be proved
Exceptions to the Tender Years Rule
Inability to provide for the children in not an exception to the tender years rule.
Removal of child from jurisdiction
There is no rule against removing a child from court's jurisdiction in a custody dispute.
Ascertainable wishes of child
A court cannot merely rely on the ascertainable wishes of a child in determining actual custody.
Opinion of the child
When determining a child's acertainable wish their age and maturity should be considered.
Conditions for Review of orders
A review of court orders in children cases must abide with O.45 of the Civil Procedure Rules, 2010.
Change of schools
Changing a child from one school to another is not in their best interests.
Substantial Loss
Denying a mother custody of a girl of tender years is evidence of substantial loss.
Consistent Routine
Children need a consistent routine including during weekdays. Access orders must be stable.
Stay of Execution
Where there is no change of circumstances stay of execution will not be granted.
Stay of Execution
Application for Stay of Execution should be made without undue delay.
Jurisdiction
A children's court cannot issue custody for children outside its jurisdiction.
Exceptions to the Tender Years Rule
Exceptions to the Tender Years Rule must be clearly demonstrated.
Grounds for review of custody orders
Custody orders in respect to a child can only be reviewed if circumstances have changed.
Proof of exceptional circumstances
The burden of proof of exceptional circumstances to the tender years principle lies with father.
Basis of seeking custody
The divorce or separation of parents is the basis for custody and maintenance cases
Stay of execution
The convenience or inconvenience of parties is not a factor to consider in staying execution.
Custody matters continous
Custody and maintenance matters can be reopened even after judgment.
Children who are non-citizens
Children who are not Kenyan are afforded same protection as Citizens under the law.
Actual custody to a working mother
The nature of work of a mother is not an exception to the tender years doctrine without proof.
Custody to biological parents
Custody to biological parents is favored than custody to inlaws.
Custody by resident parent
Actual custody to a resident parent is critical to ensure the child's best interests are met.
Exception to Tender years rule
A mother's busy schedule is not an exceptional circumstance to the tender years rule.
The wishes of a mature child
The wishes of a mature child "above the tender years" maybe taken into consideration fully.
PHYSICAL ABUSE BY A PARENT
As a safeguard, courts must ensure an abusive parent is not granted custody of a child.
SEPARATION OF CHILD
Not in best interests separating a child from a parent who has had custody for long period of time.
Access Orders
Where a court makes custody orders in favor of a party it must make access orders also.
Financial Instability
A parent's financial instability does not automatically disqualify them for actual custody.
GITHUNGURI V GITHUNGURI
Court of Appeal decision that reaffirmed the Tender years principle.
PRA
Parental Responsiblity Agreements can be vitiated just like any other contract.
Expediting children matters
Children matters that take too long to conclude prejudice a child's best interests.